Baltimore IMC : http://baltimore.indymedia.org
Baltimore IMC

Commentary :: Media

CHERYL SEAL REPORTS: 3/25: US Embassy Closes, Paper Shredder Story Fiction Exposed, Truth on Basra

The lastest anti-propaganda report: As the War bogs down, the propaganda escalates.

PROPAGANDA ALERT!! PLANTED STORY EXPOSED
Saddam Paper Shredder Shocker a Fiction Concocted and Spread by Rev. Moon and Pat Robertson

Fool me once, shame on you, fool me twice, shame on me.

Americans have a very short memory or they would have recalled that during Gulf War I, outrageous claims made about Iraqi atrocities were later admitted to be propaganda lies. Remember the "Kuwaiti babies ripped from incubators" story in 1991? That tale really got Americans whipped into a frenzy, cheering the bombers on. Then, after the war, the woman who disseminated the story for the U.S. gov. tearfully exposed the story as a total fabrication during a Congressional hearing.

Now the Bush II folks are spreading similar "urban myths" to keep American bloodlust at fever pitch. The latest: UPI (now owned by Bush's friend the Reverend Moon) and his fellow rightwing religious fanatic Pat Robertson of the Christian Broadcasting Network are currently spreading around a manufactured story about how Saddam fed an officer into a paper shredder, delighting in his screams...this lurid fiction was reported "first hand" by a "human shield pastor" who from the "Assyrian Church of the East." Turns out there is no such "pastor," and, by extension, no such person.

Here's a letter sent to Democrats.com and forwarded to me:

New York
http://johnnyasia.com
comment

I suspected the often quoted UPI story about a human shield "pastor" who "was shocked back to reality", and claimed to have proof of Saddam shredding people, was a lie, so I contacted the Assyrian Church of the East, asking for confirmation. The e-mail I sent to Bishop Soro is below, I received this reply from the Bishop:

From: ABSoro@aol.com
Date: Tue, 25 Mar 2003 08:17:47 EST
Subject: Re: Can you confirm this story?

Johnny:

The only thing that I can confirm is that Kenneth Joseph, IS NOT a pastor with the Assyrian Church of the East nor has he been associated with the Assyrian Church in any shape or form.

Bishop Soro
Secretary General of Interchurch Relations
Assyrian Church of the East

So, Robertson and Moon have added yet another new dimension to what it means to be a "good Christian": lying to promote bloodshed


MEDIA/PENTAGON LIES: 1. The Americans met some resistance and had trouble "securing" the "town" of Basra. 2. The British sent a few troops to help out. 3. The Allies decided it would be more "strategic" to consider Basra a "military target."

TRUTH: 1. The American marine unit sent to "take" Basra were overwhelmed because they were completely out of their depth and experience in this mission. No wonder - Basra is not a "town," is Iraq's second largest city. 2. The Americans were be pulled back and replaced by British troops 3.The bombing is punitive because the city gave unexpected strong resistance rather than, as predicted by Franks and Rumsfeld, welcoming the US as "liberators."

MEDIA/PENTAGON LIE: The loss of electrical power to Basra was sabotage perpetrated by the Iraqis themselves.

TRUTH: The lack of power is due to the destruction of high-power lines by U.S. bombs.

LIE: The Red Cross has restored 30% of the water supply to Basra

TRUTH: As of last night (3/24), the Red Cross Says it hasn't even been able to get into Basra, let alone supply it with water.

MORE ON BASRA:

The importance of Basra to the US is all about the oil: As a March 21 BBC report observes, "It is the "key to Iraqi's southern oil wealth. " But, ironically, to secure the oil fields, the U.S. and UK will now be bombing a city that could have been the most likely US sympathizer. As the BBC points out, "The population of Basra is made up largely of Shiite Arab Muslims, most of whom have little affection for Saddam."

This is, alas, a city that has not yet recovered from its battering by the US in 1991, when the US and UK rained down tons of depleted uranium in the area in another "precision" attack: According to a report by the Military Toxics Project, only about one-fourth of the DU projectiles found their targets, "whereas 76 per cent projectiles are presumably lying buried in sand. On hitting its target, DU catches fire and burns to oxides of uranium. Forty six per cent of this DU converts itself to depleted uranium dioxide aerosol (DUDA). Roughly, half of the aerosols are of respirable size. DUDA stays in the area for a long time. It has been fund that it survived over two years in air in Kuwait City and most certainly in Basra as well." http://www.miltoxproj.org/assesment.htm

U.S. Forced To Close Islamabad Embassy as Protests Escalate

The United States of America has ordered its Embassy in Islamabad closed as protests against U.S. policy of War on Iraq spread across the country. Non-essential U.S. Embassy staff flew out. Pakistan has enhanced security at U.S. facilities and closed roads leading to U.S. Embassy and consulates. The main opposition group, MMA, has organized nationwide strikes and anti-war protests. Many of MMA see the current U.S. war on Iraq as a war against all Muslim states.

This">http://paknews.com/top.php?id=2&date1=2003-03-24

This report is notably missing from all US sources as of 3/25 AM...it was run in MSNBC, then the story pulled - this is a link to the cached story in google

THE MEDIA EXPERTS: Patriarchal Parade of aging white men and rightwing corporate front group reps.

I have noticed a significant lack of current, active Pentagon officials being paraded before the network news cameras. Instead, I have seen an endless parade of aging white male "retired generals" - almost all, without exception, from the Reagan or Bush I years. In addition to the this stable of patriarchal hawks, I have noticed that a growing number of "experts" being relied on for "commentary" come from rightwing corporate front outfits like the "Cato Institute" (funded in large part by oil and tobacco corporations). Meanwhile, there is a stunning lack of commentary by real, independent military experts and historians.

Here are a list of foundations and Institutes that are rightwing and/or corporate backed, eager to promote the Bush agenda and known for aggressive dissemination of agenda-driven propaganda packaged as "think tank" expertise:

Heritage Foundation
Cato Institute
American Enterprise Institute
Hoover Institution
Baker Instsitute

Real experts you won't hear interviewed: most former non-general military folk who saw intensive action in Gulf War I, editors and commentators for Aviation Week (where all in depth reports on many military innovations are first published and analyzed. Yet we hear commentary on the AUVs being deployed in Iraq from the Cato Institute?), Jane's weekly (dedicated to military commentary since the late 1800s) - a headline in Jane's on 3/25 reads: "Convoy Chaos on Road to An Nasarijah" - not the sort of honest commentary the networks like see.

AOL, Home of the "Free" (er, Safe) and Not So Bright Spins Out of Control

AOL has gone from spinning headlines to telling viewers how they are supposed to react to the headlines. On the morning of 3/25 one of the mainpage "blaring" headlines was: "POW Drama Rivets America." The only way this statement could have non-propaganda validity is if AOL had 1. taken a vast, comprehensive poll of all networks, servers, radio stations to see if this specific news story was causing a dramatic surge in ratings when aired and 2 Taken a similarly comprehensive survey of Americans soliciting their personal response to the story. In short. This headline proclaims an opinionated assertion that cannot be confirmed..

Translating this headline from propagandese we get: "You are supposed to be riveted by this story because we need you to be." Why? To keep Americans focused on our POWs, not on the deaths and maimings of children and other innocent civilians in Baghdad or the miserable conditions and dangers being experienced by 250,000 other U.S. soldiers.

Another of AOL's headlines on 3/25 AM wins the Goebbels award for heavy-handed propaganda: In big bold letters on the mainpage we see "Freedom VS Safety?" The photo next to this headline is an armed soldier or swat team person - hard to tell, as he's dressed in dark blue, but has a military helmet on - standing next to a building swathed in a big US flag. In smaller letters beneath the headline is: "Sacrifice Privacy for security?"

What this propaganda tableau is saying is that Freedom = Sacrifice of privacy, and Safety = security. Lack of privacy is synonymous with freedom?

Freedom is a word being as thrown around and cheapened as the word love was during the early days of the sexual revolution. Freedom now is synonymous with everything it is NOT, from sacrificing privacy to fried potatoes....soon no American will really know what the word truly means anymore. And then, what is left of it will be so easy to take away.

Other AOL headlines are simply irresponsible: "KNOCKING ON SADDAM'S DOOR!" This implies we are on the verge of a victorious assault on Baghdad, while "WE KNOW WE HIT SADDAM!" implies we have all but triumphed over the "Evildoer." To fuel such a false sense of positive expectation in Americans, many of whom have family members in the front lines to me constitutes a psychological war crime - in fact, it amounts to aiding and abetting the enemy, by inducing dangerous overconfidence in Americans, who will thus root the war on, not knowing that they are pushing their own men into what will likely prove a protracted hell.

American Media War Propaganda Widening Gulf between Us and Rest of World

On C-SPAN on the morning of 3/25, during the short segment I caught, there was seriousd concern raised by callers on the lack of coverage by the American mainstream media of the "other side" - the damage sustained by Iraqis. One woman had been shocked when she had seen photos of injured and dead Iraqi children on the BBC. These photos had hit home, she said - there were real people, real children caught in beneath the bombs of "shock and awe." Other callers expressed similar concerns.

But to hear the American media cover it, this war is all about "speeding through the desert," Americans being shot down or captured, grieving American families, reporters standing statically in front of tanks, and aging generals (dozens and dozens of aging generals, enough to go around to every TV and radio station in the country, apparently, as "commentators"). War, according to the American media, has nothing to do with the suffering of the opposition - with little girls with their heads half-blown off (see http://democrats.com ) or homes and livelihoods destroyed forever, or grieving Iraqi families.

Yet, the rest of the world is seeing both sides, and sees that what the American soldiers are enduring is but a tiny fraction of the suffering the war is inflicting on Iraqi civilians - worse, that this entire scenario is being forced on Iraq by Bush. Even the Christian Science Monitor ran a story today about how American media is creating, through its one-sided coverage, a widening gulf between Americans and the rest of the world. While we are led to believe through a steady diet of propaganda that our war really is "just" afterall, the rest of the world sees reality: this is a bloody, brutal, cruel war, just like most wars, and we are inflicting, promoting and, worse yet, glorying in it.

 
 

This content is now locked, and no comments may be added.

Comments

Re: CHERYL SEAL REPORTS: 3/25: US Embassy Closes, Paper Shredder Story Fiction Exposed, Truth on Basra

I know we are getting only one side of the war story, but most Southern white males don't care and support Bush's war no matter how much the damage is to the Iraqi people.

Martha Hulsey, Odessa, TX
 

Re: CHERYL SEAL REPORTS: 3/25: US Embassy Closes, Paper Shredder Story Fiction Exposed, Truth on Basra

This war has been open to correspondents to keep the U.S. informed. They seem to be siding with our troops in most cases. It is great the Cheryl Seal has the scoop on all of them. I hope the shreading story is false, but from what I hear from people who lived under Sadam he seems brutal. I hope Cheryl's article will appear nation wide soon.
 

Re: CHERYL SEAL REPORTS: 3/25: US Embassy Closes, Paper Shredder Story Fiction Exposed, Truth on Basra

A 5-second Google search took me to this web page, which contains the lengthy biography of Kenneth Joseph's father.

www.edessa.com/profiles/revkenny.htm

Kenny Joseph is an Assyrian Christian Evangelist, who has served mostly in Asia since 1947. I asume he is not affilited with the American church you contacted. The Rev. Kenny Joseph has 4 chilren, including Kenneth Phillip Joseph, who is also an evangelist.

A little more research is in order before declaring that "there is no such "pastor," and, by extension, no such person." Did you not even take the time to do a Google search???? What does this say about the quality of YOUR reporting???
 

Re: CHERYL SEAL REPORTS: 3/25: US Embassy Closes, Paper Shredder Story Fiction Exposed, Truth on Basra

A 5-second Google search took me to this web page, which contains the lengthy biography of Kenneth Joseph's father.

www.edessa.com/profiles/revkenny.htm

Kenny Joseph is an Assyrian Christian Evangelist, who has served mostly in Asia since 1947. I asume he is not affilited with the American church you contacted. The Rev. Kenny Joseph has 4 chilren, including Kenneth Phillip Joseph, who is also an evangelist.

A little more research is in order before declaring that "there is no such "pastor," and, by extension, no such person." Did you not even take the time to do a Google search???? What does this say about the quality of YOUR reporting???
 

Re: CHERYL SEAL REPORTS: 3/25: US Embassy Closes, Paper Shredder Story Fiction Exposed, Truth on Basra

omg, a story sent to democrat.com----it must be true!!! Let's see. You're running for village idiot?
 

Re: CHERYL SEAL REPORTS: 3/25: US Embassy Closes, Paper Shredder Story Fiction Exposed, Truth on Basra

If the Church of the East states that they do not know of Ken Joseph Jr. - then why has this gentleman written an article for the church which appears on line at:
www.thechurchoftheeast.com/news_oct_29_02.htm
Titled: "The Forgotten Christians"
????

Now WHO is planting propoganda?????
Appears to be you.....

~Kim Petersen
Germany
 

Re: CHERYL SEAL REPORTS: 3/25: US Embassy Closes, Paper Shredder Story Fiction Exposed, Truth on Basra

I am a journalism student. A responsible news organization would issue a retraction and apologize to UPI in this situation. It will be interesting to see if Baltimore.Indymedia or Cheryl Seal does either.

So far, they have done neither, and that says a lot about the credibility of this site. Why should we believe anything else that is reproduced here, without even the most basic attempt at verification of sources?

What we see here does not appear to be journalism, but simply the exchange of email gossip.

The second greatest sin in journalism is to fabricate a story out of whole cloth.

The greatest sin is to falsely accuse someone else of doing so without making even the most basic effort to verify the facts.
 

Re: CHERYL SEAL REPORTS: 3/25: US Embassy Closes, Paper Shredder Story Fiction Exposed, Truth on Basra

This email is obviously a fake.

Here is Kenneth "Kenny" Joseph's bio:

tinyurl.com/8cp0

Kenny Joseph is an Assyrian Christian missionary, born in Chicago, Illinois on October 30, 1928. His father Samuel Noah Joseph and mother, Martha Adams Joseph fled to America after a holocaust when more than 180,000 Christians were massacred by Turkish Muslims during WWI.
 

Re: CHERYL SEAL REPORTS: 3/25: US Embassy Closes, Paper Shredder Story Fiction Exposed, Truth on Basra

Yours is the third web page provided on this man they claim not to be a "real person." Moreover, the web pages provide all the contact information any journalist would need:

1. His street address
2. His mailing address
3. His telephone number
4. His fax number

Yet here we are, 4 days later, and no retraction or no correction. This makes a mockery of the Mission Statement on this site, the first sentence of which is as follows:

"The Independent Media Center is a global network of collectively run media outlets for the creation of radical, accurate, and PASSIONATE TELLINGS OF TRUTH."

I have but one question for Cheryl Seal: Do you feel you have told the PASSIONATE TRUTH about the existence or non-existence of pastor Kenneth Joseph?
 

Re: CHERYL SEAL REPORTS: 3/25: US Embassy Closes, Paper Shredder Story Fiction Exposed, Truth on Basra

From the bottom of each page: "The views expressed herein are not necessarily those of the Baltimore Independent Media Center collective. Caveat lector!"

Baltimore Indymedia is a small collective of people who all have other full-time jobs. Unfortunately, we don't have the time to fact-check every article that is posted to the newswire. That's how open publishing works. However, because we have comments show on the same page as the article, other people can correct/discredit posts, just like happenned here. You can also down-rate a post, which if enough people do it will automatically "hide" it.
 

Rating system doesn't work

The concept that false stories will disappear by down-rating obviously does not work. The original post alleging that Kenneth Joseph does not exist has been thoroughly discredited by many subsequent posters, yet it continues to appear at the top of the page. In fact, the original "Report" is still rated an 8!

This site apparently subsititutes popular opinion for the truth. Since when has the "truth" been determined by a popular vote. The people who run this website have abdicated even the minimal responsibility to remove stories which are shown to be false. Failure to do this editing undermines the credibility of the entire site, and casts doubt on other stories here which are in fact true.

I, too, have a full time job, and can't afford to go to a web site where the burden is upon the reader to fact-check the stories. There are simply too many other alternative sources of news on the web.
 

Re: CHERYL SEAL REPORTS: 3/25: US Embassy Closes, Paper Shredder Story Fiction Exposed, Truth on Basra

Just go to Japan Times' website, where Kenneth Joseph Jr. (your photo below is not the "human shield" Joseph, but either his dad or grand-dad), and do a search of articles written by him in the past 2 years (their index is online). Betcha can't find a SINGLE article concerning the war, or antiwar sentiments, or announcing his intention to go to Iraq!

On the Assyrian Christian websites, look for a single mention of preious antiwar activity, such as mentioned on his homepage- years and years of articles, radio shows, speeches. Can't find a single one on the web, either. Wonder why?

Funny how none of the human shield organizations seem to know who is, either. And funnier still, how does a Christian missionary from Japan hook up with a bunch of American or British antiwar activists (whose names and organizational affiliations are never mentioned).

I
 

On veracity and open publishing...

The maintainers of this website have not abdicted their responsibility. Our goal is to provide a forum for the open exchange of information, coming from sources in the community. The veracity of these claims is always somewhat in question, just as a wealth of articles on this site should lead you to believe that even the "fact-checked" claims of the mainstream media should be as well.

One of the goals of the Indymedia movement is not only to provide alternative news coverage, but to encourage people to actively engage in media criticism -- to read the news with a critical eye. The notion that news "consumers" should have blind faith in the veracity of what's being reported is exactly how the media are used, repeatedly, by governments and corporations to manipulate public opinion.

I personally don't agree to the particular phrase "Turns out there is no such 'pastor,' and, by extension, no such person." -- I suspect that the Archbishop selected his words carefully when he stated that Joseph "is not a pastor" (he is always described as a "missionary", which may well be a self-imposed title).

Nonetheless, the issues raised by this controversy -- users attempting to locate and verify the information being fed to them -- means that this site is accomplishing at least part of its goal.

Please note that the "Open Publishing" newswire is provided by visitors to this site, not the Baltimore IMC. The center-column "Feature" articles are, however, produced by Baltimore IMC editors, and checked for facts as much as is feasible, just as one would expect of a news organization.
 

Re: CHERYL SEAL REPORTS: 3/25: US Embassy Closes, Paper Shredder Story Fiction Exposed, Truth on Basra

Thank God for reporters like yourself, I think if Americans were somehow exposed to the truth more often, there may be a real shift in the polls, to one showing this "WAR" not to be so popular.. The real word for this situation should be "SLAUGHTER", of the Iraqi people, and of the American Ideal.. The name of the game is conserative politics as usual, which is lie upon lie, regardless of a few little casulties, and a little "collateral" damage. bush (not capatalized) wants control of the "OIL", I know I must be wrong, because bush, (Jesus) tells me so... Ed Ridge, Lake Havasu City, AZ.
 

Re: CHERYL SEAL REPORTS: 3/25: US Embassy Closes, Paper Shredder Story Fiction Exposed, Truth on Basra

Cheryl Seal, you need to go to the book store, buy a BIBLE, and "dig" through the many books until you locate the 15+ verses in which GOD supports war against evil dictators at ANY cost!!
 

Re: CHERYL SEAL REPORTS: 3/25: US Embassy Closes, Paper Shredder Story Fiction Exposed, Truth on Basra

Kenneth Joseph is so obviously an agent working for the US government. A very large number of missionaries and others in the Christian scene are either CIA operatives or assets. If you want to know what really gives concerning Kenneth Joseph, just read the article entitled "Wag the Kennel? The Kenneth Joseph Story" on www.counterpunch.org/lipton04122003.html . Just like the fictitious "rescue" of Pte Jessica Lynch, Kenneth Joseph the anti-war protester turned hawk is classic propaganda straight out of the psyops department. When will people wise up??!!
 

Re: CHERYL SEAL REPORTS: 3/25: US Embassy Closes, Paper Shredder Story Fiction Exposed, Truth on Basra

I have been associated with Kenny Joseph Sr since his arrival in Japan as a missionary in 1951 and his son Kenny Joseph Jr since I arived in Japan in 1985 to become a seminar president of after serving as a pastor myself in the USA for some twenty years. As an earlier poster pointed out a little surfing of the Internet would have vouch safed the Joseph's reputations. You have done a great disservice to (the TRUTH) both men's careers in serving their fellow man as they serve the Lord. The veracity of Kenny Joseph Jr's work is unquestionable and with his father the over 50 years of research that is helping rewrite Asian history is a tremendous academic achievement! You have stumbled over the truth failing to recognize it and tossed your reputation into the wind--for me and those who know !! Shame on you!
 

Views

Account Login

Calendar

No events for this day.

view calendar week
add an event

Donations

Help support us!

RSS Syndication

Media Centers

 

This site made manifest by dadaIMC software